OK, I give up. If you have a band, and you feel the need to rip off Joy Division, then by all means, please do so. Consequently, this also results in a record deal. I'm not going to even be indignant anymore. I'm just going to accept that it's a sign of the times and a by-product of what I will lamely call "The Pursuit of Cool." Let's deconstruct.
The Pursuit of Cool begins very humbly. Usually those involved are branching off of another "cool" movement, going their own way to create a new and different product. These pioneers normally do not achieve a high level of success and the project is typically short lived. A good example of this would be Joy Division. Joy Division broke off from the late 1970s London punk scene to craft a much darker, somber music. Joy Division was short-lived and while they did find some success, it was not until after the suicide of singer Ian Curtis that the band's popularity began to really grow.
Through the 1980s, Joy Division remained "cool," inspiring other "cool" bands to branch off from the somber rock and post-punk movement and create new music and form new movements, most notable of these are the Cure and the Goth Movement.
The cool kids that listened to these "cool" old bands then grew up to start bands of their own to showcase their talents and influences, using the "cool" bands from their past as both inspiration but also as a "cool" springboard to quickly push their band into the consciousness of other "cool" people who liked those "cool" old bands. I will refer to this mimickery, intentional or otherwise, as "cool dropping." Cool dropping, like name-dropping is an effective way to make other people think you are more knowledgeable or cool simply by knowing the proper band names (AKA, what I do here every other day).
This, however, is where the Pursuit of Cool falters. Instead of branching off of the current movement and creating a new sound, these new "cool" bands are simply rehashing musical history and "cool dropping" as a short cut to fame, money and "coolness" as opposed to doing the proper thing by recording music no one will understand for another ten years, not making any money and then committing suicide (which, by the way, is now another form of "cool dropping," thanks Cobain).
So that's it. In case you are wondering, here's the current list of bands unwilling to risk the Quest of Cool:
Interpol, Elefant, She Wants Revenge and the Editors. For the record, this is simply an interpretation. I like Interpol and am currently really enjoying the Editor's The Back Room. But I don't care for the rest of it. And that is also an important part of cool . . . having a completely outrageous double standard.
Website: Editors, Interpol and Suckfest 1 and Suckfest 2
Stuff to Sample: From the Editor's The Back Room "Blood" from Interpol's Antics "Narc" from Joy Division's Substance "Love Will Tear Us Apart"
Update: Just found out that the Editors are signed to Sony BMG. How sad.